for all your insurance needs

Personal Lines

Tara Hunter

Tara joined the agency in December of 2020. She is new to the insurance industry and is very eager to learn. She has been working in the Berlin office as a Customer Service Representative, and will soon pursue her Property & Casualty Insurance license. Tara is a 2011 graduate of West Holmes, and lives in Killbuck with her husband Brian, their cat Toby, and their dog Max. In her free time, Tara enjoys being outdoors, going on Razr trips with her husband, and spending time with her 6 nieces (Makenzi, Scarlet, Sawyer, Juliette, Alayna, and Jovie) and 2 nephews (Noah, and Ethan). 

Tyler Wallace

Tyler joined the TMA team May of 2020 and is an agent out of our Berlin location. He started in the insurance world in 2016 and loves working and creating relationships with his clients. He resides with his wife Kali in New Philadelphia and they have a son named Audie. Tyler has served in the US Army and loves to study military history along with spending time with his family.

Hannah Armstrong

Hannah joined the Troy Miller Agency in 2019, and is part of our personal lines team in the Berlin office. Hannah lives in Millersburg, OH and enjoys raising beef cattle with her husband Clay in their spare time. 

Maggie Boggs

Maggie joined our personal lines team in December of 2017. She has been a licensed agent since 2004. Maggie enjoys customer interaction and loves helping others. She resides in Wooster with her husband Aaron and son Lincoln. In her free time she enjoys making jewelry, going for long walks and enjoying a good concert.

Penni Stertzbach

Penni joined the Troy Miller Age in February of 2017 and works in the Shreve location. She has worked in the insurance industry since 1988. Penni genuinely enjoys working with local clients and assisting them with their insurance needs. She lives near Millersburg with her husband Don and has one daughter, Jenna. When not at the office she enjoys reading and spending time with her family and friends.

Tasha Pruitt

Tasha began her insurance career in April of 1998. She is currently licensed in property, casualty, life & health. Tasha joined our team in May 2015. She enjoys working with clients and is very much a people person. Tasha is a graduate of Triway High School and currently resides in the Wooster area along with her husband Rich and their three children JR, Haylee and Tyler. In her free time she enjoys watching her daughter’s fast pitch softball team, camping and spending time with her family.

Felicia Messner

Felicia joined our team August of 2013 and works in our Berlin office. In her eyes, the best part about working in the Insurance industry is being able to help others and the relationships it creates. Felicia is a West Holmes graduate and resides in Millersburg with her two cats Roscoe and Brooke. In her free times she enjoys teaching gymnastics and cheerleading at the Berlin Resort, along with scrapbooking.